DIYrr

Replacing Deck Boards Is DIY

Updated 2026-10-28 · Sources verified 2026-07-20

Have this exact problem? Snap a photo or describe it and get a free step-by-step plan — local prices and the permit answer included, and you can email the plan to yourself. No signup. Get my free plan →

"Above ground" is not decided by whether the wood touches dirt. Permit in Orange County: no permit for like-for-like boards. Replacing walking-surface boards like-for-like is repair. The full answer and its source are below, with the code requirements and mistakes that trip up Orlando homeowners.

Key facts before you start

The permit answer

No permit for like-for-like boards. Replacing walking-surface boards like-for-like is repair. Touching the STRUCTURE — joists, ledger, posts, stairs, or guardrails — or building new is structural work: Orange County requires building permits for all structural changes, and the under-$7,500 exemption never covers structural work.
Source: https://www.orangecountyfl.net/PermitsLicenses/DivisionOfBuildingSafety.aspx

Orange County and the City of Orlando run separate permit offices with separate portals — and your mailing address alone doesn't tell you which one covers your home. Check which permit office covers your address →

Deck Board Replacement: what it looks like

Replacing one Trex deck board in four steps: unscrew the hidden fasteners, angle the new board in, slide the fasteners back, screw them down
Replacing one Trex deck board in four steps: unscrew the hidden fasteners, angle the new board in, slide the fasteners back, screw them down Image: Trex Company, used with permission
Trex deck boards with the 3/16 inch width-to-width gap marked
Trex deck boards with the 3/16 inch width-to-width gap marked Image: Trex Company, used with permission
Where Trex deck boards meet end-to-end and end-to-width, the gaps that depend on temperature
Where Trex deck boards meet end-to-end and end-to-width, the gaps that depend on temperature Image: Trex Company, used with permission

Manufacturer instructions

The manufacturers' own instructions this guide is built from. Follow the manual for your exact model; they open on the manufacturer's site.

What it costs

DIY: Composite deck boards alone run $4–$16 per sq ft in materials (HomeGuide's composite-decking survey); wood boards are the cheapest option
Hiring it out: $175–$875 per board typical for pro replacement, or $25–$125 per sq ft installed — wood $25–$50, composite $40–$80, PVC $50–$80 per sq ft installed
Wood vs composite is the main price fork: composite costs more up front but is usually replaced only for fading, not rot.
Published national figures (HomeGuide, checked Aug 2026): https://homeguide.com/costs/deck-repair-cost. Prices move — the free planner pulls current retail prices for your exact repair.
Get a free step-by-step plan for YOUR exact repair →

DIYrr builds a personalized plan from a photo and description — tools, materials with local prices, and permit guidance. Email it to yourself to keep it. Free for homeowners, no account needed.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a permit for a deck board replacement in Orange County, FL?

No permit for like-for-like boards. Replacing walking-surface boards like-for-like is repair. Touching the STRUCTURE — joists, ledger, posts, stairs, or guardrails — or building new is structural work: Orange County requires building permits for all structural changes, and the under-$7,500 exemption never covers structural work.

Are there specific building-code requirements for a deck board replacement?

FBC-R R317.3.1: fasteners for preservative-treated wood must be "hot-dipped, zinc-coated galvanized steel, stainless steel, silicon bronze or copper" and "Staples shall be of stainless steel"; zinc coating weights per ASTM A153; connectors follow the connector maker, else minimum ASTM A653 G185.

What does a deck board replacement cost?

DIY: Composite deck boards alone run $4–$16 per sq ft in materials (HomeGuide's composite-decking survey); wood boards are the cheapest option Hiring it out: $175–$875 per board typical for pro replacement, or $25–$125 per sq ft installed — wood $25–$50, composite $40–$80, PVC $50–$80 per sq ft installed Wood vs composite is the main price fork: composite costs more up front but is usually replaced only for fading, not rot. Published national figures (HomeGuide, checked Aug 2026) — local prices vary, and the free DIYrr planner pulls current retail prices for your exact repair.

Looking for a different repair?

Sources

https://awpa.com/images/standards/U1excerpt.pdf
https://awpa.com/images/standards/ResidentialInfographic2021.pdf
https://awpa.com/info/technical/homeowners
https://www.strongtie.com/products/product-use-information/corrosion-information/pressure-treated-wood-faq
https://www.yellawood.com/resources/building-with-yellawood/building-tips/
https://www.yellawood.com/resources/building-with-yellawood/kdattips/
https://online.flippingbook.com/view/63974767/
https://up.codes/viewer/florida/fl-residential-code-2023/chapter/3/building-planning
https://up.codes/viewer/florida/fl-residential-code-2023/chapter/5/floors
https://www.ocfl.net/PermitsLicenses/Permits/ResidentialAccessoryStructures.aspx
https://laws.flrules.org/2026/63

This guide is general informational content, not professional or legal advice. Codes and county rules change — confirm permit requirements with your local building department, and use a licensed professional for electrical, gas, structural, or main-line plumbing work.

© 2026 Karhan Companies LLC · Orlando, FL · DIYrr app · All guides · Tips library · About · Contact · Privacy · Terms